Gun Talk

[ClearedHot]

8 hours ago, Smokin said:

No, but if you get one, please let us know.  That looks awesome and I want one, although I could see the 9mm not generating enough gas to cycle properly.  Have a WWII original, but I generally try not to shoot those guns much, more of the safe queens...

My brother in law is now a deputy chief of police but ran weapons and his departments SWAT team for many years.  I was able to train with them a few times and when he first started their officers were carrying the Marlin 9MM carbine modified to accept Glock Magazines.  The rationale was officers only had to carry one type of mag for both pistol and rifle.  I shot it many times in training and it was able to cycle with no jams.  It shot well and was easy to use during transition but my BIL converted the unit to M-4 Carbines because he was worried about stopping power of the 9MM at distance.

Still not convinced after watching several videos...dependability is a big issue for me.

13 hours ago, Lord Ratner said:

So about the Keltec PR57...

It's kinda great.

[Lawman]

One of the biggest seen benefits of moving to 5.56 by teams that started doing it was the shatter factor of the round leading to lower over penetration of residential walls.

That and the higher degree of idiot proof seen in the AR platforms led to a lot of departments ditching the MP5, which while very sexy is a more expensive and intensive weapon to keep up in an armory.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[M2]

Army infantry officer calls new XM7 ‘unfit for use as a modern service rifle’

[busdriver]

22 hours ago, Lord Ratner said:

So about the Keltec PR57...

It's kinda great. It's *very* thin, so thin......

I've only put 150 rounds through it, so it'll take a few more trips to the range to be sure, but for $400 it's a pretty cool gun and quite fun to shoot.

I'll mirror these comments.  I put a Vortex CCW on mine.  The dot is wider than the pistol.  

Mine is not accurate.  At all.  It'll suffice at close range, but a shooter it is not.  Might be the dot mount I guess. I haven't trouble shot it yet.

It flings the empty cases a really long way.  Like comically far.

 

[Lord Ratner]

5 hours ago, busdriver said:

I'll mirror these comments.  I put a Vortex CCW on mine.  The dot is wider than the pistol.  

Mine is not accurate.  At all.  It'll suffice at close range, but a shooter it is not.  Might be the dot mount I guess. I haven't trouble shot it yet.

It flings the empty cases a really long way.  Like comically far.

 

I wonder if you have a bad unit. This is mine at 10 yards using just the stock sights. I'm not going to win any competitions, but the gun is more accurate than I am. I've also been using a red dot as a crutch for so long my iron-sights skills have definitely atrophied. 🫣

 

[busdriver]

On 5/9/2025 at 7:21 PM, Lord Ratner said:

I wonder if you have a bad unit. 

Maybe.  I haven't had the time to delve into it too much.  When I shot it, I was just using the head box of a USPSA target at about 10 yards after a match.  Probably a 4 inch group or so.

The dot plate screws sit above the plate, so the dot mount is janky.  ???  Beats me.  

[Lord Ratner]

54 minutes ago, busdriver said:

Maybe.  I haven't had the time to delve into it too much.  When I shot it, I was just using the head box of a USPSA target at about 10 yards after a match.  Probably a 4 inch group or so.

The dot plate screws sit above the plate, so the dot mount is janky.  ???  Beats me.  

It's a Kel-Tec. Janky is included free of charge 

 

 

[busdriver]

10 minutes ago, Lord Ratner said:

It's a Kel-Tec. Janky is included free of charge 

It is the Florida-Man of gun companies.

[Lord Ratner]

 

Yup... 

[M2]

To be honest, I've gotten a bit bored with this guy's videos as they seem to focus on his dumping endless amounts of ammo and massaging his ego.  He knows his shit, but it's always SS/DD i.e., wash, rinse and repeat...

Plus, I've also lost much interest in pistol caliber carbines for the time being for some reason.

Still sharing for anyone interested...
 

 

[ClearedHot]

38 minutes ago, M2 said:

To be honest, I've gotten a bit bored with this guy's videos as they seem to focus on his dumping endless amounts of ammo and massaging his ego.  He knows his shit, but it's always SS/DD i.e., wash, rinse and repeat...

Plus, I've also lost much interest in pistol caliber carbines for the time being for some reason.

Still sharing for anyone interested...
 

 

I watched as I am in the market form a small carbine and it looks like it comes up short.  As he mentions there are numerous MP-5 knockoff coming so I will likely wait.