Jump to content

Champ Kind

  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by Champ Kind

  1. Is that the full story? Pretty sure APZ rates overall have gone up in recent years. Agree that it is a shame that boards are apparently disregarding a senior rater’s DP promotion recommendation, especially when they only have so many allocated and them giving it to an APZ was one less available for an IPZ.
  2. What are the reserve call out rules at SWA?
  3. https://www.iragreen.com/air-force/rank-insignia/major-sew-on-desert-brown.html
  4. Fair enough for that snapshot in time. I knew of the one, I didn't make the connection on the second. I know that one of those individuals would acknowledge that their career path was certainly the exception. I'd be surprised if the other didn't do the same. So, back to the point... yes, it's possible. Yes, it occurred twice in a relatively small span of time. The takeaway should be that it's possible, but certainly not something to which someone should plan.
  5. This is a pretty accurate breakdown of the process. What cannot be overstated is the impact individual personalities have on this process. My experience has been that hiring authorities will very, very rarely directly tell a prospective CC that they are in their plan. CC selection remains one of the least transparent processes in an officer's development. Based on the daynightindicator's comment above, this appears to be a substantial difference between MAF and CAF. Furthermore, even if you're told one-on-one by a hiring authority that you're "in the plan", that is almost exclusively followed with a caveat of "but things can change." These changes can be anything from the hiring authority changing his/her mind, to having a ranking officer implant a hire into a wing's game plan. Edit to add: like most things, timing is everything. You have a 50% chance of finding yourself in a situation where the wing commander/hiring authority that's in the seat when PE nominations are due will not be the person that does the actual hiring after he/she leaves command in a typically two-year summer PCS cycle... yet another impact of individual personalities.
  6. I haven't posted in a while, but this thread got my attention. Define "many", please. I can't think of a single current sitting CC in the AD Herk community that didn't do residence IDE. I know of enough in other MAF communities to be able to confidently say that a vast majority of sitting CCs completed IDE in residence. I don't mean to call you out, but I think we owe it to the OP and anyone reading now and in the future to keep the conversation based on fact.
  7. What’s the first year group wholly affected by the BRS only/no pension at 20 years deal? Will people in that year group (or those that opted in) even be motivated to stick it out till 20? I doubt it.
  8. What counts as experienced in the fighter community? Certain amount of hours? Flight lead or instructor certification? Sent from my iPhone using Baseops Network mobile app
  9. Short of a no-shit criminal act, I’d say “none”. Also, P vs DP from an IDE student MLR is irrelevant.
  10. How many people have you ever heard of getting passed over for promotion while attending or having finished in-res IDE?
  11. I’m sorry... what’s your definition of shiny penny again? Because you just threw out three different categories of people in that statement, all of which fall into very different rankings in my opinion.
  12. I’m having a hard time recalling a single time that promotion results were released before the AFPC estimate. I’d go with that.
  13. Spot on. Also, to those saying that no consideration should be given to IPZ vs APZ, my concern would be the quality of his(?) records that led to getting passed over in IPZ. Seldom does that much change in a year.
  14. Assertiveness works, too. So does verbiage from the regs that works to your advantage.
  15. What is this "company culture" you speak of? In all seriousness: I hear this about SWA all the time. Can you elaborate some more and provide some specific examples? I'm particularly curious since once of the attractions of the airline industry (in any company) is the "show up, fly, leave airport, don't think about work until the next trip" mentality, so how good could a culture really be (or matter) if you're making good coin to fly airplanes anyway.
  16. Not if they went first or second look.
  17. Congrats. The DP at least gets you in the correct pile at the board. No chance without that. Your actual chances of selection are based on several things. First, it has to be more than just your PRF and OPR on top. If you’ve got a string of OPRs with #1 rank/grade based wing strats (ie, #1/100 Wg Capts....not 1/35 IPs), that’s good. If you’ve got multiple DGs (not the least of which from SOS), that’s even better. Jobs with proven leadership and responsibilities are a must. Your PRF being signed by a GO or at least a wing CC of a large wing is a decent boost too. Finally, being at the top of a large denominator of eligibles really helps. I’ve seen SRs actually push some BTZs above IPZs by stratting then as 1/XX eligibles (not just BTZ) with a push that said something like “1/XX eligibles ahead of X IPZ....he’s that good.” You have all of those things, and you’re definitely in decent shape. If only one or two or only shades of what I described, I’d put your chances in the single digits as mentioned in the post above. Either way, I’d use this year’s process (and your BTZ DP) as a positive indication that you’ll make it IPZ (in case you’re trying to make life plans as far as getting out/staying in).
  18. Copy. Your remarks make a lot more sense now.
  19. Your position on the topic is obvious. For context, would you mind sharing your aircraft and if you graduated from WIC?
  20. Don’t forget the HC rescue mission creep too.
  21. True in so many ways, regardless of “special” program, school, or even experience.
  22. I know what you meant, but for clarity, I think the exact program at which you’re (rightfully) spewing hate is Phoenix Reach (ie, MDS crossflow). Phoenix Eagle is the MAF squadron CC selection board for O-5s and O-5 selects.
  • Create New...