Cagg011,
Let me know how this goes. I got PDQ that I'm trying to fight for a shoulder surgery that was done in 2007, Posterior labral repair and chondoplasty for grade 2 chondromalacia. I was suppose to see a consultant after MEPS but it went straight to DQ. I had my surgeon give a good letter too, saying " no symptoms in right shoulder and full range of motion and strength.
Strange thing is, my recruiter is saying it was an automatically disqualifier, but I had to submit all my docs beforehand and get a waiver to even "floor"/ be able to take the physical, so if it was an automatically disqualifier, why would they even let someone go to MEPS if they are just going DQ them. Drs at MEPS don't really check you a whole lot, pretty much just write down what's in your medical files that you provide them.