Got grief from Tampa approach today for following a TCAS resolution advisory even though we had the traffic in sight. Vol 3 talks about it being "imperative" to follow any resolution advisories, but there is no must/shall wording I could find. My feeling is that we did the right thing, especially considering the RA could have been for some other airplane we might not of had in sight. (ie. we could have had eyeballs on the wrong plane) Third RA for me in 2 weeks...should be done with them for now I guess. Anyway, you guys have any thoughts?
Edit...looking further 202-v3 pretty much says you have to follow an RA. The more my gears spin on this one the more I think the controller was an idiot.
5.29.1.1. Pilots shall respond to all RAs as directed by the TCAS system, unless doing so would
jeopardize the safe operation of the aircraft (e.g., descent into obstacles).
Edit 2:
From 217v3 pretty much black and white:
6.9.4.3. Traffic acquired visually may not be the traffic causing the RA, or it may not be the only
aircraft to which TCAS is responding.
Nice one man thread here...